Founders
Startup job offer checklist: how to evaluate a startup
To evaluate a startup job offer from an early-stage startup, check five things: how long the cash lasts, what your stock options are really worth, what you will own in your opening months, whether the founders are straight with you, and whether you can afford the downside. A job at a startup can pay off, but you carry part of the company’s risk.
Why a startup offer needs its own checklist
An established employer gives you a salary, a title and a fairly predictable year. A young company gives you a smaller salary, a share of a business that may be worth nothing, and a role that will probably change twice before you get comfortable in it. Guides on how to evaluate a startup agree on that much, and most of them add that the company has to earn your trust with evidence, and enthusiasm alone will not do it.
The list below turns those guides into twelve checks you can run in a week of interviews and conversations. You do not need a perfect score. You need to know which answers are missing and decide whether you can live with that.
The 12-check list
- Your reason for going. Write down what you want: learning speed, a bigger scope, a possible payout, or simply a change. A startup that cannot deliver your reason is the wrong startup, however good it looks.
- Stage and funding. Is it bootstrapped, seed, or already past a Series A? Earlier stages carry more risk and more room for you to shape the company, later stages behave more like larger firms.
- Real customers. Find out who pays, how much, and how many would complain if the product vanished. Recurring revenue is a better sign than one-off projects.
- The founders. Watch how they explain decisions, how they speak about people who left, and whether they have done this before. Talk to people outside the interview loop.
- Cash left. Covered in the next section; a vague reply is itself an answer.
- Role clarity. What problem do you own, who do you report to, how is success measured, and what authority comes with it?
- Cash pay and benefits. Check that the salary covers your life, then compare benefits and time off with your alternatives.
- Your stake. Request it as a percentage of fully diluted shares, not only a count of options.
- Option terms. Vesting schedule, cliff, strike price, exercise window, dilution and what the company can buy back.
- Career value. If the company folds in eighteen months, which skills and results do you keep?
- Culture and workload. How does the team handle deadlines, mistakes and bad news?
- Personal risk. How many months can you live on savings, and what is your plan if the company runs out of money?
How to read cash and burn
Runway, the months a company can last, is its cash divided by monthly burn. Human Interest, in an article reviewed in January 2024, gives a simple example: $80,000 in the bank and a $10,000 monthly burn leave eight months. It calls less than six months of cash troubling and notes that shrinking companies tend to cut staff first.
Put three questions to them. How many months of cash are left at today’s spending? What must happen before the next raise, and when? What gets cut first if it does not come? A founder who answers in numbers is giving you something to check. One who changes the subject has also told you something. Our piece on why a start-up needs a CFO explains why a clear view of cash is an early sign of a company that will still exist next year.
Stock options: get the numbers, then discount them
Options are a right to buy shares at a fixed price later, and they are worth something only if the company is sold or goes public for more than that price. Harshal Patil, writing about his own seed-stage offer, lists the questions to put in writing: strike price, current fair market value, the share of the company your grant represents, the last valuation, and how future rounds will dilute you. He also asks how long you have to exercise after leaving and whether the company can buy the shares back.
Human Interest adds a valuation example: an investor putting in $1 million for 25 percent implies about $4 million before the money and $5 million after. The higher that pre-money number, the less of the company a given investment costs the founders to give away. Our guides to how a company gets funded and to warrants cover the financing side of that math.
Patil also quotes a rough rule of thumb of equity worth 50 to 90 percent of annual salary. It is one author’s rule, not a standard, so treat it as a starting point for a conversation. A useful test several guides share: would you still take the job if the equity ended up worth zero? Verbal promises to take care of you later should not count toward the comparison.
If you are the first product manager hire
A first PM has no predecessor, and often no roadmap that anyone fully trusts. Interview guides for product people suggest checking a few things in particular.
- Who decides. Plenty of founders pride themselves on product vision. Find out where their calls end and yours begin.
- Evidence for demand. What data shows customers want this, and how will the company get more if it has little?
- Stage honesty. Find out whether there is product-market fit, a working prototype, or a push to scale. Startups often move to the next stage before finishing the last.
- Competition. A team that says it has none is worth a follow-up.
- Working relationships. Find out how you will work with engineering, design, sales and support, and whether anyone there has worked with a PM before.
The same logic applies to any founding hire in a function: finance, design, data or operations. Consider what the person before you would have needed, and why nobody has filled the seat yet.
Red flags during the process
- Refusal to share even a rough cash figure.
- Promises about stock made only in conversation, never in a document.
- A role that changes each time you ask about it.
- Founders who speak badly about former employees.
- Pressure to sign within a day or two.
- An expectation of founder-level commitment on an employee’s pay.
One red flag is a reason to ask a follow-up question. Several together are a reason to walk away.
Once you have accepted: a new-hire checklist
- Get the offer, the option grant and the vesting terms in writing, and keep copies.
- Confirm whether you are an employee or a contractor, since taxes and benefits differ.
- Request the opening 30, 60 and 90 days in plain terms: one project, one owner, one measure of success.
- Book short conversations with each founder, your manager and two people from other teams.
- Learn the numbers early: monthly revenue, burn, runway and the main retention metric. Our overview of activation, retention and churn is a good place to start for software companies.
- Read about common finance mistakes at young companies so you can spot them before they cost you.
- Keep a running list of the questions nobody could answer. Check it again after ninety days.
Questions readers ask
How do I know if a startup is a good place to work? Check months of cash, paying customers, the leaders’ track record and how openly they answer. No single item proves it.
Should I take lower pay for stock options? Only if you can live on the salary and would accept the job with worthless shares. Get the terms in writing before deciding.
What should I ask in the interview? Months of cash left, the next funding milestone, what success looks like for your role by mid-year, and how decisions get made.
Is it too risky to join an early-stage company? It is riskier than an established employer. Savings, other offers and your reasons for leaving your current job decide how much risk fits you.
Sources and limits
Cash and valuation examples come from Human Interest, “33 questions to help evaluate a startup job offer” (page last reviewed January 2024). Option questions and the 50 to 90 percent rule of thumb come from Harshal Patil’s seed-stage offer guide. The 12 checks draw on Startup Editor’s “Should I join a startup?”, the CoffeeSpace early-hire guide, and product-manager interview advice from Olga Shavrina, Nina Klein and The Product Thinker. These are advice articles, not research, and the figures are examples rather than benchmarks. This article is general information, not financial, legal or tax advice. Have a lawyer read any option agreement before signing.