Startup finance
Startup Financial Statements: Audit, Review, Compilation
An audit, a review and a compilation are three levels of outside accountant involvement with your financial statements. A compilation gives no assurance, a review gives limited assurance and an audit gives reasonable assurance. Most startups begin with internal financial reporting or a compilation, and move up only when a lender, investor or regulator asks.
What each one is
All three are services a CPA firm can provide on financial statements, and they differ in how much the accountant checks and how much comfort the reader gets. Firms that publish plain-language guides, including CMP, BPM and Trullion, describe them in nearly the same way.
Compilation. The accountant takes the financial data management supplies and arranges them into financial statements under a chosen framework, such as US GAAP, tax basis or cash basis. The numbers are not verified, and the report provides no assurance. Independence from the company is not required, but if the accountant is not independent, the report has to say so (BPM, November 2025).
Review. The accountant asks management questions and runs analytical procedures, such as comparing this year with last year and checking whether the relationships make sense. The result provides limited assurance: the accountant reports whether anything about the financial reporting came to their attention that suggests the financial statements need material modifications. Source documents and internal controls are not tested, and the accountant does not perform detailed testing. Independence is required.
Audit. An independent CPA tests the financial statements and the records behind them and issues an opinion on whether they are free of material misstatement. BPM lists what that can involve: testing internal controls, assessing fraud risk, confirming balances with outside parties and observing inventory counts. The assurance it provides is called reasonable, which is the highest level available and still not a guarantee, because auditors work with samples and judgment.
In the United States, the AICPA’s standards for the first two sit in its SSARS codification: AR-C section 70 covers preparation, section 80 covers compilation and section 90 covers review, as the Journal of Accountancy summarized in a 2017 article. Section 70 also covers a plain preparation engagement, where the accountant prepares statements without a compilation or review report.
| Compilation | Review | Audit | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Assurance | None | Limited | Reasonable |
| Main work | Formatting your figures | Inquiry and analytics | Testing, confirmations, controls |
| Independence | Not required, disclosed if absent | Required | Required |
| Typical time | A few days | A few weeks | Weeks to months |
| Relative cost | Lowest | Middle | Highest |
The time ranges come from CMP’s 2026 guide. None of the guides I checked published fee figures I could verify, so this page gives only the order of cost and not prices.
Who actually requires which one
The short rule is that the level is set by whoever is asking for the financial information, not by the accountant. CMP’s guide says to confirm the requirement with the requester before you hire anyone, and it points out that many non-accountants say “audit” when they mean any statements prepared by a CPA.
Business requirements that come up for startups:
- Public companies. SEC-registered companies need audits under PCAOB standards, according to Trullion’s 2026 overview. Few startups are anywhere near that.
- Federal grants. Trullion lists organizations that spend $1 million or more in federal awards as required to have an audit, known as a Single Audit.
- Equity crowdfunding in the US. SEC Regulation Crowdfunding ties the level to the size of the raise. According to 17 CFR 227.201, an offering of $124,000 or less needs figures certified by the principal executive officer, above $124,000 up to $618,000 needs financial statements reviewed by an independent public accountant, and above $618,000 needs audited financial statements. A first-time issuer may use reviewed statements up to $1,235,000. If audited statements already exist, the rules require using them.
- Regulation A. The SEC explains that Tier 2 offerings need audited financial statements prepared under AICPA or PCAOB standards, while Tier 1 does not require an audit unless audited statements were already prepared for another purpose.
- Bank loans and credit lines. BPM says banks making larger loans typically want a review or an audit, and smaller financing may accept a compilation. CMP adds that a loan agreement may call for a particular level, so the covenant text matters more than any general rule.
- Investors. Trullion notes that a review can come up at early growth stages when investors ask for CPA involvement, and that a full audit may be expected in complex financing or in an acquisition. Investor requirements differ from deal to deal, and I did not find a rule that applies to all venture rounds.
Hypothetical: three startups, three answers
These are made-up examples built on the real Regulation Crowdfunding thresholds above, to show how the logic works.
- A pre-seed team raises $100,000 through a crowdfunding portal. Under the rule, a certification by the CEO is enough, so no CPA report is required for the offering.
- A seed-stage company raises $400,000 the same way. That falls between $124,000 and $618,000, so the statements must be reviewed by an independent public accountant.
- A company running its first crowdfunding round for $900,000 may stay with a review, since it is under $1,235,000. A company that has already used crowdfunding and returns for $900,000 needs an audit.
The same question applies off-platform: what does the person writing the check or the covenant say, in writing?
What drives the cost
Without verified price lists, the useful thing to know is what pushes a quote up or down.
- Level of service. CMP and BPM both put compilations lowest, reviews in the middle and audits highest, because testing is deeper.
- Size and complexity. More entities, locations and transaction types mean more work. BPM names related-party dealings and complex accounting issues as complications.
- Condition of the records. CMP’s CPA commentary says reconciled bank statements, a clean general ledger and documented unusual transactions shorten reviews and audits. Messy books turn into billable hours.
- Timing. CMP’s guide puts a compilation at a few days, a review at a few weeks and an audit at weeks to months, and the hours billed follow the calendar.
Strong monthly closes help with every one of these. The routines described in our guide to building a startup budget and forecast produce the reconciled, dated records that an accountant asks for first.
When a startup should move up a level
A reasonable path, based on the guides above, looks like this:
- Early stage. Internal statements, plus a compilation if a bank or landlord wants business financial information from an accountant. Trullion calls a compilation a sensible start for early-stage businesses building reporting habits.
- Raising outside money or borrowing more. Expect a request for reviewed financial statements, particularly at crowdfunding or lender thresholds.
- Larger financing, acquisitions, regulated activity or a public listing. Plan for an audit. Groundwork helps before the request arrives: close each month on time, keep support for large transactions and write down your accounting policies.
Financial statements also feed investor diligence. What a data room usually needs is covered in due diligence and data room preparation, and the person who owns the close, often a controller, is explained in CFO vs controller vs VP finance.
SOC 2 is a different thing
Founders sometimes hear “audit” from a customer and assume it means financial statements. A SOC 2 report is something else, and it provides no financial reporting opinion. It belongs to the AICPA’s System and Organization Controls services, where a CPA examines controls at a service organization against criteria such as security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality or privacy. It says nothing about whether your income statement is fairly stated. A SaaS company may need a SOC 2 report for enterprise sales and a financial statement review for its lender, and the two engagements run separately.
Common mistakes
- Paying for an audit when the requester accepts a review. Ask first and get the requirement in writing.
- Buying a compilation and presenting it as verified. It carries no assurance, and the report says so.
- Assuming that tax preparation means your books were reviewed. A review is its own engagement with its own report.
- Starting audit preparation after the request arrives. Clean closes and sound internal controls are slow to build in a hurry.
More general slips are listed in top finance mistakes startups make, and related guides sit in the startup finance section.
Questions readers ask
Is a compilation worth buying for a startup? It gives no assurance, so its value is in presentation and in meeting a lender or landlord who asks for financial statements prepared by an accountant. If nobody asks, internal statements may do.
Is a review the same as a light audit? It is a separate service. A review relies on inquiry and analytics and gives limited assurance, while an audit tests records and gives reasonable assurance.
Can the same firm that does my bookkeeping audit me? Audits and reviews require independence, according to BPM, so ask the firm how it handles that before you sign.
Do venture investors require audited financial statements? Sources I checked did not give a universal rule. The financing documents set the requirement, so read that section of the term sheet.
Does a SOC 2 report replace a financial statement audit? No. They cover different subjects.
Sources and limits
- CMP, “Audit vs Review vs Compilation” (blog.cmp.cpa), published 2025, updated August 2026
- BPM, “Audit vs. Review vs. Compilation: What’s the Difference?” (bpm.com), November 2025
- Trullion, “Audit vs. Review vs. Compilation” (trullion.com), April 2026
- AccountingTools, difference between an audit, a review and a compilation (accountingtools.com), October 2026
- Journal of Accountancy, “Preparation and compilation standards” (journalofaccountancy.com), January 2017
- SEC, Regulation A financial statement requirements (sec.gov), accessed November 2026
- 17 CFR 227.201, Regulation Crowdfunding disclosure requirements (law.cornell.edu), accessed November 2026
- AICPA, System and Organization Controls services (aicpa-cima.com), accessed November 2026
These are US sources. Canada, the UK and other countries use different standards and thresholds, and Canadian readers should check with their provincial regulator and a Canadian chartered professional accountant. Most firm guides are marketing material from accounting firms, and dollar thresholds such as the crowdfunding limits are adjusted from time to time. This guide is general information, not accounting, tax or legal advice.