Case studies
Dropbox IPO case study: S-1 unit economics and outcome
Dropbox filed its S-1 on February 23, 2018, showing more than 500 million registered users, 11.0 million paying users and 2017 revenue of $1,106.8 million, with a net loss of $111.7 million. It priced its shares at $21 on March 22 and closed its first trading day at $28.48. This page sets out the filed facts first and keeps interpretation separate.
Timeline
- February 23, 2018: Dropbox files its S-1 with the SEC, proposing to list Class A shares on the Nasdaq Global Select Market under the ticker DBX.
- March 22, 2018: The company prices the offering at $21.00 per share. The prospectus (Form 424B4) covers 36,000,000 shares: 26,822,409 sold by the company and 9,177,591 by selling stockholders.
- March 23, 2018: Trading begins. According to TechCrunch, the stock closed at $28.48, a gain of almost 36% over the offer price.
- February 2019: Dropbox reports full-year 2018 results, the first full year as a public company.
What the S-1 disclosed
All figures below come from the S-1 and the later 2018 results release unless marked as calculated.
| Metric | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paying users (millions, year end) | 6.5 | 8.8 | 11.0 | 12.7 |
| Revenue ($ millions) | 603.8 | 844.8 | 1,106.8 | 1,391.7 |
| ARPU ($ per paying user) | 113.54 | 110.54 | 111.91 | 117.64 |
| Net loss ($ millions) | 325.9 | 210.2 | 111.7 | 484.9 |
| Free cash flow ($ millions) | -63.9 | 137.4 | 305.0 | 362.4 |
| Gross margin (calculated or reported) | about 32.5% | about 53.8% | 66.7% | 71.6% |
The 2015 and 2016 gross margins are calculated from the gross profit lines in the S-1; the 2017 and 2018 margins are the reported GAAP figures. The 2018 column comes from Dropbox’s fiscal 2018 results release (February 2019), not the S-1. The 2018 GAAP net loss is far larger than 2017; this page does not analyze the reasons, and the S-1 cannot explain it because it covers earlier periods.
Freemium conversion
The S-1 does not state a free-to-paid conversion rate. It gives two inputs: more than 500 million registered users and 11.0 million paying users at the end of 2017. Dividing one by the other gives roughly 2.2%. That is a calculation made for this page, and it overstates precision, because the filing says registered users are not unique people and one person may hold several accounts.
The filing says the company estimated that approximately 300 million registered users had at least one characteristic it believed made them more likely than other registered users to pay over time. It also says over 90% of revenue came from self-serve channels, meaning customers who bought through the app or website rather than through a sales team.
Paying users grew about 35% in 2016 and about 25% in 2017 (calculated), while ARPU stayed within a few dollars of $110 to $114. Revenue growth of 40% in 2016 and 31% in 2017, as stated in the S-1, therefore came mostly from more paying users and little from higher prices.
Offering and first-day trading
Per the 424B4, Dropbox receives none of the selling stockholders’ proceeds. TechCrunch reported total funds raised of $756 million (the 36 million base shares at $21) and a price above the revised range of $18 to $20, which itself had been lifted from $16 to $18. It also reported a fully diluted market value above $12 billion at the first close. Underwriter over-allotment and net proceeds are not covered here.
Lessons
This section is editorial interpretation, not a statement from Dropbox or its filings.
- Report the metric you can defend. Dropbox disclosed paying users and ARPU, which can be counted, and left out a headline conversion rate that would have rested on a loose user count.
- Cash flow and net loss can disagree. Free cash flow was positive in 2016 and 2017 while GAAP net loss persisted, so readers of any startup’s financials should check both and ask what sits between them.
- Margin work shows in the history. Gross margin rising from about 32.5% to 66.7% over three years is a trend a financial model should be able to explain line by line.
- A small paying share can carry a large business. A low single-digit share of registered users still produced over $1.1 billion in revenue, and the same arithmetic makes churn and acquisition cost the numbers to watch.
Related reading: SaaS math on activation, retention and churn, SaaS pricing, billing and freemium, startup financial dashboard, burn rate and runway and startup exits and earn-outs.
Sources and limits
- SEC, Dropbox Form S-1, filed February 23, 2018 (sec.gov)
- SEC, Dropbox Form 424B4 prospectus, March 2018 (sec.gov)
- Dropbox Q4 and fiscal 2018 results, exhibit 99.1, February 2019 (sec.gov)
- TechCrunch, March 23, 2018, first-day trading report
Press reports give slightly different first-day closing prices ($28.42 and $28.48); this page uses the figure from TechCrunch. The 2018 paying-user count and later years are outside the IPO window and are included only for context. Figures marked calculated are arithmetic from filed numbers, not company statements.