Case studies
Spotify direct listing vs IPO: what the F-1 and 20-F showed
Spotify began trading on the New York Stock Exchange on April 3, 2018, through a direct listing. No new shares were sold and no underwriter ran the process. Its prospectus showed €4,090 million of 2017 revenue, a 20.8% gross margin and a €1,235 million net loss, much of it tied to convertible notes. The NYSE reference price was $132, the stock opened at $165.90 and closed at $149.01.
Timeline, with documents
- February 28, 2018: Spotify Technology S.A. filed its Form F-1 with the SEC (file number 333-223300). F-1/A amendments followed on March 14, March 20 and March 23 (SEC EDGAR filing list).
- March 23, 2018: Date of the final prospectus, which registers 55,731,480 ordinary shares for resale by existing holders. The prospectus states that the company receives none of the proceeds.
- April 2, 2018: The NYSE published a reference price of $132 per share (CNBC, April 2, 2018).
- April 3, 2018: First day of trading under the ticker SPOT.
- February 12, 2019: Spotify filed its first annual report on Form 20-F, for the year ended December 31, 2018 (SEC EDGAR).
How the listing worked
Before April 3, 2018 there was no public market for Spotify’s ordinary shares, only private transactions. The prospectus says the resale of the registered shares was not underwritten by any investment bank, so the company hired no one to sell stock to the public. Latham & Watkins writes that no fixed number of shares was being sold to the public. The market for the shares formed on the exchange from orders placed by buyers and by holders choosing to sell, which is the main difference from an underwritten IPO, where the company and its banks fix the price and the allocation before trading starts.
The numbers in the filing
Spotify reports in euros under IFRS as issued by the IASB. The figures below come from the March 2018 prospectus unless a different source is named. Gross margin is gross profit divided by revenue, calculated for this page.
| Item, € millions | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 (20-F) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 1,940 | 2,952 | 4,090 | 5,259 |
| Gross profit | 226 | 401 | 849 | 1,353 |
| Gross margin (calculated) | 11.6% | 13.6% | 20.8% | 25.7% |
| Operating loss | (235) | (349) | (378) | (43) |
| Net loss, owners of the parent | (230) | (539) | (1,235) | (78) |
At December 31, 2017 the prospectus reports 157 million monthly active users, 71 million Premium subscribers and 90 million ad-supported users. Revenue grew about 52% in 2016 and about 39% in 2017 (calculated). The 2018 column comes from the first 20-F, dated February 12, 2019, and falls outside the listing window.
Royalty costs and thin margins
The prospectus says cost of revenue consists predominantly of royalty and distribution costs. Other items in it include payment processing fees, customer service, cloud computing and streaming costs. No euro split by component appears in the parts of the filing read for this page.
Royalty terms set a ceiling on margin. The prospectus describes royalty payments as variable, depending on factors such as the revenue generated, the size of the user base and the ratio of ad-supported users to Premium subscribers, with minimum guarantees and most-favored-nation provisions that could raise payments substantially. Its results discussion states that Premium cost of revenue fell from 84% to 78% of Premium revenue and that ad-supported cost of revenue fell from 112% to 90% of ad-supported revenue. Total cost of revenue was €3,241 million on €4,090 million of revenue in 2017, about 79% (calculated).
A gap of that size leaves little room for other costs. Gross margin rose from 13.6% to 20.8% in 2017, yet the operating loss still widened from €349 million to €378 million.
Why the net loss was so much larger than the operating loss
In 2017 the operating loss was €378 million, but the net loss was €1,235 million. The difference sits below the operating line. The prospectus reports finance costs of €974 million in 2017, against €336 million in 2016, and net finance costs of €855 million, against €186 million.
The prospectus ties a large part of this to convertible notes.
| Term | As stated in the prospectus |
|---|---|
| Principal | $1,000 million, issued at par on April 1, 2016 (agreement dated March 24, 2016) |
| Interest | 5.0% payment in kind, rising by 100 basis points every six months after April 1, 2018 |
| Conversion discount | 20.0% to the ordinary share price, rising 250 basis points on April 1, 2017 |
| Accounting | Carried at fair value, with changes in fair value recorded in the statement of operations |
| Carrying amount | €1,106 million at December 31, 2016; €944 million at December 31, 2017 |
The prospectus gives the 2016 fair value expense on the notes as €245 million and says the 2017 expense rose by €279 million, which implies about €524 million (calculated). It does not break down the rest of the 2017 finance costs in the passages read for this page.
Three exchanges retired the notes. In December 2017 the company exchanged $301 million of notes for 4,800,000 ordinary shares in what the prospectus calls the Tencent Exchange. A further $110 million went for 1,754,960 shares in the same month. In January 2018 the remaining $628 million, plus accrued interest, was exchanged for 9,431,960 shares. If the shares were not listed by July 2, 2018, the company had agreed to offer each noteholder an option to unwind the exchange. Pro forma for the January exchange, the prospectus reports no outstanding indebtedness.
Reference price and first day
A direct listing has no offering price. The NYSE published a reference price of $132, and CNBC quoted the exchange as saying it was neither an offering price nor the opening public price. The prospectus states that the opening price would be determined by buy and sell orders the NYSE collects from broker-dealers.
Before the listing, the prospectus reports private-transaction prices of $37.50 to $125.00 in 2017 and $48.93 to $132.50 from January 1 to March 14, 2018, excluding the Tencent transactions. Latham & Watkins, in a July 2018 case study, noted that the $132 reference was in line with the highest private sale in that window.
| Item | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Reference price | $132.00 | CNBC, April 2, 2018 |
| Opening price, April 3 | $165.90, about 25.7% above reference | Latham & Watkins, July 2018 |
| Closing price, April 3 | $149.01, about 10.2% below the open | Latham & Watkins, July 2018 |
| Day-one volume | 30,526,500 shares | Latham & Watkins, July 2018 |
| Shares outstanding, March 21, 2018 | 178,112,840 | Prospectus |
Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and Allen & Company served as financial advisers. According to Latham & Watkins, they did not build a book, attend investor meetings or support the price, and the designated market maker consulted Morgan Stanley on the opening.
What it meant for existing shareholders
The prospectus registered 55,731,480 shares for resale, roughly 31% of the 178.1 million outstanding (calculated). Latham & Watkins describes the other shares as available under Rule 144 for non-affiliates who had held them for at least one year, and says Spotify kept the registration effective for 90 days after its effective date. There was no IPO-style lock-up, so holders could sell from the opening bell, at market prices.
One group was restricted. Affiliates of Tencent Music Entertainment and Tencent agreed not to transfer shares for three years from December 15, 2017, subject to listed exceptions. Selling was optional for everyone else: holders could sell some, all or none.
Control stayed where it was. The prospectus lists the substantial control the founders have through concentrated voting power as a risk, and refers to beneficiary certificates issued in February 2018.
Reporting as a foreign private issuer
Spotify Technology S.A. reports under IFRS as issued by the IASB, not US GAAP, and its first annual report was filed on Form 20-F rather than Form 10-K. The prospectus lists risks related to its status as a foreign private issuer; this page did not verify the specific reporting exemptions, so check the filing before relying on them.
The same document discloses material weaknesses in internal control, including at December 31, 2015, 2016 and 2017.
What a startup CFO can take from it (editorial interpretation)
This section is the editorial team’s reading of the facts above, not a statement from any filing.
- Read the lines below operating loss. A company with a €378 million operating loss reported €1,235 million of net loss. Models that stop at operating income miss that gap.
- Gross margin depends on contracts. When royalty terms set the cost of each user, margin work starts with the contracts.
- Convertibles with a rising discount carry a cost. Fair value accounting put those changes into the statement of operations. See SAFEs and convertible notes.
- Settle the cap table before the listing. The exchanges of notes into shares were completed before trading began.
- Choose the reporting basis early. Spotify reported under IFRS and filed Form 20-F, which differs from the US GAAP and Form 10-K pattern.
Questions readers ask
Did Spotify raise money in the listing? No. The prospectus states the company would not receive proceeds from sales by registered shareholders.
Is the reference price a valuation? The NYSE said it is not an offering price or an opening price. It was a starting point for matching orders.
Why did the stock open so far above the reference price? CNBC reported that a designated market maker would use the buy and sell orders collected by the NYSE to find a single price where buyers and sellers could be matched; Reuters named the market maker as Citadel Securities. Latham & Watkins says Morgan Stanley consulted it on the opening. The sources read for this page do not explain why the match landed at $165.90, and this page does not guess.
Were any new shares created for the listing? The prospectus registered existing shares for resale, and the company received no proceeds from those sales.
How is this different from Slack? Slack’s 2019 listing is covered on its own page, with its prospectus numbers. See the Slack direct listing case.
Where can I compare an underwritten IPO? See the Dropbox IPO case and the Airbnb IPO case.
Related reading
More examples sit in the case studies hub. For process and roles, see the CFO’s role in an IPO, startup exits and earn-outs, secondary sales and tender offers and the glossary.
Sources and limits
- Spotify Technology S.A., Form F-1 filed February 28, 2018, and EDGAR filing list for amendments of March 14, 20 and 23, 2018 (sec.gov, CIK 1639920).
- Spotify Technology S.A., Form 424B4 prospectus dated March 23, 2018 (sec.gov). Read in sections: summary, risk factors, selected data and MD&A. Financial statement notes were not read.
- Spotify Technology S.A., Form 20-F for 2018, filed February 12, 2019 (sec.gov). Cover page and selected data only.
- CNBC, April 2, 2018, on the NYSE reference price.
- Latham & Watkins, “Spotify Case Study: Structuring and Executing a Direct Listing,” July 5, 2018, via the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance. Source for the opening and closing prices, volume, Rule 144 and the adviser roles.
Limits: market value on listing day, later share performance and the 2018 user counts are not covered. Calculated figures are arithmetic on filed numbers, not company statements. This is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice.