Case studies
Instacart IPO Case Study: Down Round and RSU Withholding
Maplebear Inc., which operates Instacart, priced its IPO at $30.00 on September 18, 2023, which valued the company at about $9.9 billion fully diluted, against $39 billion in a 2021 private round. The filings also showed that listing would trigger a tax withholding bill of roughly $570 million on employee equity. This page sets out the filed facts first and keeps interpretation for the end.
Timeline
- February 2021. The prospectus says Instacart sold 2,120,000 shares of Series I preferred stock at $125.00 per share, for $265 million. Press coverage (Fortune, September 18, 2023) put the company’s private valuation from the 2021 round at $39 billion.
- March 25, 2022. TechCrunch, citing a Bloomberg report, wrote that Instacart had cut its valuation from about $39 billion to $24 billion. Commentary in the article suggested the new figure came from a 409A price change (a third-party appraisal of common stock) and not from a change in the price of preferred shares.
- September 18, 2023. Instacart announced pricing of 22,000,000 shares at $30.00 on the Nasdaq Global Select Market under the ticker CART. Trading was expected to start on September 19 and the offering to close on September 21 (Instacart press release, September 18, 2023).
- September 19, 2023. According to AP (via KSAT), shares peaked at $42.95 in the first minutes and closed at $33.70, up 12.3%, for a market value of more than $11 billion.
- September 21, 2023. The IPO closed. Maplebear sold 14,100,000 shares, then 5,833,333 shares of Series A preferred stock in a private placement at $30.00 (Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2023). The prospectus names PepsiCo as the buyer of the preferred stock.
What the prospectus showed
The figures below come from the Form 424B4 prospectus dated September 18, 2023, and the 10-K for 2023. Dollar amounts are in millions unless stated.
| Metric | 2021 | 2022 | 6 months 2022 | 6 months 2023 | 2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gross transaction value (GTV) | 24,909 | 28,826 | 14,356 | 14,937 | 30,322 |
| Orders (millions) | 223.4 | 262.6 | 132.3 | 132.9 | 269.2 |
| Total revenue | 1,834 | 2,551 | 1,126 | 1,475 | 3,042 |
| Transaction revenue | 1,262 | 1,811 | 799 | 1,069 | 2,171 |
| Advertising and other revenue | 572 | 740 | 327 | 406 | 871 |
| Net income (loss) | (73) | 428 | (74) | 242 | (1,622) |
| Stock-based compensation | 22 | 33 | 13 | 9 | 2,756 |
| Adjusted EBITDA | 34 | 187 | (20) | 279 | 641 |
The 2023 column comes from the 10-K, which Instacart filed after the IPO; the other columns come from the prospectus. Advertising and other revenue was 29% of 2023 revenue (871 of 3,042, calculated).
Advertising and other revenue was 31% of total revenue in 2021, 29% in 2022 and 28% in the first half of 2023, according to the prospectus. GTV grew about 16% from 2021 to 2022 (calculated) while revenue grew 39% (calculated). The prospectus also states that 2022 net income included a $358 million tax benefit from releasing the U.S. deferred tax asset valuation allowance. Without it, 2022 net income would have been about $70 million (calculated).
Pricing and size
The prospectus cover shows 22,000,000 shares at $30.00, a total offering price of $660,000,000. Of those, 14,100,000 came from the company and 7,900,000 from selling stockholders. Underwriting discounts were $1.65 per share, or $36.3 million. Proceeds before expenses were $399,735,000 to the company and $223,965,000 to the selling stockholders, who sold their shares for their own account. The underwriters held a 30-day option for up to 3,300,000 more shares.
A concurrent private placement committed $175 million of Series A preferred stock, convertible at $30.00. The 10-Q later reported $392 million of net IPO proceeds after discounts and offering costs, and $175 million from the preferred placement. The amended S-1 filed September 15, 2023 gave an expected range of $28.00 to $30.00, so the final price was at the top.
The valuation gap
At $30 the share price was 76% below the $125 paid in 2021 (calculated). The $9.9 billion fully diluted figure reported by Fortune on September 18, 2023, is about 75% below $39 billion.
Two different prices sit behind those headlines. A priced round sets the price of preferred shares, which carry rights such as liquidation preference. A 409A appraisal sets the value of common stock for option strikes and can move without any new financing. The sections of the filings read for this page do not describe the 2022 repricing, so that step rests on press reports. For how a lower price affects earlier investors, see down rounds and anti-dilution and startup valuation basics.
Stock-based compensation and the RSU tax bill
Stock-based compensation (SBC) was small before the IPO: $64 million in 2020, $22 million in 2021 and $33 million in 2022, per the prospectus. The prospectus said Instacart expected to recognize $2.4 billion of expense tied to restricted stock units (RSUs) and restricted stock when the registration statement became effective, measured as of June 30, 2023. In other words, the expense for many earlier grants had been held back until the listing.
Settling RSUs creates a tax obligation for the employer. The prospectus said Instacart intended to use net proceeds of the offering and the private placement, plus existing cash if needed, to meet tax withholding and remittance obligations on RSU settlement. It estimated those obligations at about $568.6 million, using the $30.00 price and assumed withholding rates of 47% for RSUs and 43% for options, against about $563.8 million of net proceeds. The main RSU net settlement covered 12,977,282 shares, and further awards could add $80.3 million.
What the later filings reported:
- The Q3 2023 earnings release (8-K, November 8, 2023) showed SBC of $2,605 million for the quarter, mostly cumulative vesting tied to the IPO, and a GAAP net loss of $1,999 million, against net income of $36 million a year earlier. Quarterly revenue was $764 million and adjusted EBITDA $163 million.
- The 10-Q showed $570 million of “taxes paid related to net share settlement of equity awards” and cash and cash equivalents of $2,010 million at September 30, 2023.
- The 10-K for 2023 put full-year SBC at $2,756 million and net loss at $1,622 million. It states that the tax withholding obligation was $570 million, paid in the third quarter.
In net settlement the grocery delivery company withholds part of the shares an employee would receive and pays cash to the tax authorities in their place. The employee ends up with fewer shares and Instacart spends cash at the moment of listing.
What a startup CFO can take from it
This section is editorial interpretation, not a statement from the company.
- Model the gap between paper and public value. A 2021 preferred price of $125 became a $30 IPO price at the IPO. A plan that treats the last round as the exit reference deserves a downside case. See startup exits and earn-outs.
- Track three prices. The preferred price, the 409A value and a future IPO price can all differ. Keep the cap table and option strike analysis current, as covered in founder equity and stock options.
- Size the withholding cash early. The filed estimate of $568.6 million sits close to the $570 million later paid. The inputs are the number of RSU shares settling, the expected price and the assumed tax rate, and the share price at settlement moves the cash need directly.
- Plan the funding source. Instacart tied the tax payments to IPO proceeds and a preferred placement arranged alongside the offering. Other routes, such as employees selling shares to cover taxes, change dilution and cash differently. This page does not rank them.
- Read GAAP loss next to adjusted EBITDA. In 2023 Instacart reported a $1.6 billion net loss and $641 million of adjusted EBITDA. The filings tie the loss to the charge for IPO-triggered vesting. A startup financial dashboard can carry both views.
- Disclose one-offs next to profit. The prospectus reported 2022 net income of $428 million and said it included a $358 million tax benefit. Stating the adjustment in the same place helps readers judge the figure.
For other listings on this site, see Airbnb’s pandemic IPO, Dropbox’s 2018 IPO, the wider case studies hub and the CFO’s role in an IPO. Terms such as 409A and RSU are defined in the glossary.
Questions readers ask
Was the Instacart IPO a down round? In price terms, yes. Shares sold at $30.00 against $125 for preferred stock in 2021, and the $9.9 billion fully diluted value compares with $39 billion. The phrase “down round” comes from press coverage, not from the prospectus.
Did the company pay the RSU taxes in cash? The 10-Q and 10-K show $570 million of taxes paid on net share settlement in the third quarter of 2023. The prospectus said proceeds from the offering and the private placement were intended for this purpose.
Why did a company with positive adjusted EBITDA report a large net loss? The 8-K and 10-K tie the 2023 loss to a cumulative SBC charge of about $2.6 billion recognized at the IPO for awards granted before Instacart went public.
How much of revenue came from advertising? The prospectus gives 29% for 2022 and 28% for the first half of 2023. The Q3 2023 release shows $222 million of advertising and other revenue on $764 million of total revenue, about 29% (calculated).
Sources and limits
- SEC, Maplebear Inc. Form 424B4 prospectus dated September 18, 2023 (sec.gov).
- SEC, Maplebear Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2023, Form S-1/A filed September 15, 2023, and Form 8-K with Q3 2023 results (November 8, 2023).
- SEC, Maplebear Form 10-K for 2023, filed March 2024.
- Instacart, press release announcing IPO pricing, September 18, 2023.
- Fortune, September 18, 2023; TechCrunch, March 25, 2022; AP via KSAT, September 19, 2023.
Prospectus figures were read through text extraction, so check the original for exact wording. The original S-1 and valuation changes after March 2022 were not read. Several publishers blocked automated access and are not cited. This is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Information as of November 2026.