Case studies
What happened to Zirtual: the 2015 startup shutdown
Zirtual, a US startup that supplied virtual assistants to busy professionals, stopped operating in the first days of August 2015 and told its staff by email. Its founder said spending outran revenue and its funding round fell through, leaving the business unable to pay for the virtual service it sold. Its former outsourced CFO said the business model was the problem. This page lays out what was reported, then separates opinion from fact.
Timeline of reported facts
Accounts differ on small details, so each line names its source.
- 2011. Zirtual launches. Its base plan, as CNN reported in 2015, was 16 hours of assistance a month for $399.
- Before the shutdown (date not given). According to the founder’s essay, the company moved its assistants from independent contractors to employees, and she wrote that costs “skyrocketed”. She estimates employee costs at 20 to 30 percent above contractor pay. The essay gives no month for the change.
- March 2015. Zirtual announces 100 new jobs on the West Coast (CNN, August 2015).
- April 2015. An outsourced CFO firm stops working with Zirtual (Fortune, August 13, 2015).
- Summer 2015. Zirtual looks for new money. Fortune reported a planned $3 million round at a $38 million pre-money valuation. A smaller venture firm that was set to fill out the round pulled out the Thursday before the shutdown, according to Fortune.
- August 7, 2015. Last day of work for staff, according to CNN.
- August 9 to 10, 2015. The founder and CEO, Maren Kate Donovan, emails the whole company. CNN gives the time as 1:34 a.m. on Monday, August 10. The email said operations had ended.
- August 11 to 12, 2015. Startups.co, a company that runs several tools for founders, agrees to buy Zirtual in an all-stock deal. The price was not disclosed. Fortune reported on August 12 that the service would restart the following week.
The numbers that were published
No audited accounts were released. Every figure below is a number given by a company insider or counted by a news outlet, and the sources do not always agree.
| Item | Reported figure | Source and year |
|---|---|---|
| Capital raised | $5.5 million | Crunchbase, cited by CNN, 2015 |
| Capital raised (founder’s words) | “nearly $5 million” over three years | Donovan essay, 2015 |
| Staff at shutdown | “just under 400” | CNN, 2015 |
| Staff at shutdown | “more than 400” | Fortune, 2015 |
| Staff at peak | “almost 500” | Donovan essay, 2015 |
| Run rate at peak | $11 million | Donovan essay, 2015 |
| Assistant pay | $11 to $12 an hour, with benefits | Keating via Fortune; one employee via CNN |
| Planned round | $3 million at $38 million pre-money | Fortune, 2015 |
| Planned pay rise | assistants to $16 an hour | Fortune, after correcting an earlier $18 figure |
What the founder said
In an essay published on August 12, 2015, Donovan gave a one-word cause: burn. She wrote that the company grew faster than it could manage and that spending spiraled even with high revenue. She said she tried to raise money until the last days, that the company was not well capitalized for its size, and that because it could not meet the next payroll the law required her to end all employment at once.
She also told Fortune that projections from the outsourced CFO firm had missed that May and October each contained three pay periods instead of two. The essay states that final pay, refunded benefit charges and unused leave would be paid.
What the former CFO said
Ryan Keating, whose firm Keating Consulting Group had worked with Zirtual, told Fortune he built the projections on two pay periods a month and raised the cash assumption in each period to offset it. He said he could not imagine that gap had a large effect on getting through mid-August. In his view, the move from contractors to employees with benefits cut margins, held pay at $11 or $12 an hour, and kept turnover high, which meant planning to hire 20 to 30 percent more people than needed. He also said the company knew it would have to raise money in the summer of 2015, and that he had not followed its fundraising after his firm’s work ended. He described Donovan as a great CEO.
What the buyer said
Wil Schroter, CEO of Startups.co, said in Fortune coverage that he was still unsure whether anyone from the management team would stay, and that he planned to hire a small number of assistants. Schroter’s own explanation, as relayed by Fortune, was that Zirtual had grown its staff faster than demand.
Customers and staff
CNN reported that clients lost service immediately and that one employee said a customer who had prepaid for a year was out more than $5,000. Donovan wrote that assistants would be paid for time worked. Press coverage at the time said former assistants could apply to return, as contractors rather than employees.
Lessons (editorial interpretation)
Everything above this heading is reported, with a source. The points below are this site’s reading of those facts and are not findings of any court, regulator or auditor.
- Rebuild the cost model before a staffing change. The founder and the former CFO both point to the contractor-to-employee switch as the moment margins changed. Testing that change against realistic price, pay and turnover assumptions would have shown the gap early. See how burn rate and runway work.
- A round that is not closed is not cash. The planned $3 million existed only as commitments. Plans that depend on one pending round leave no room for a delay. A simple financial dashboard that shows weeks of payroll cover makes that dependence visible.
- Payroll calendars belong in the model. Whether or not the three-pay-period issue mattered, the dispute shows how a small calendar detail can become a talking point. The traits of a good financial model include clear, checkable inputs.
- Hiring ahead of demand raises fixed cost. Headcount reached nearly 400 by the shutdown, and Schroter’s later comment points the same way.
- Finance ownership needs one clear owner. Two people with different explanations of the same numbers is a sign that nobody was reconciling them. The question of when a startup needs a CFO is partly about that.
- How staff hear the news matters. They learned of the shutdown by email in the early hours, and the press criticized that widely.
More examples are in the case studies section.
Sources and limits
- CNN Money, “Zirtual shut down”, August 11, 2015 (read via the GantNews republication)
- Fortune, “Zirtual’s outsourced CFO gives his side of the shutdown story”, August 13, 2015
- Fortune, “Zirtual returns, Startups.co”, August 12, 2015
- Maren Kate Donovan, essay on Zirtual’s shutdown, August 12, 2015, as reproduced by Fortune
- Entrepreneur, reprint of the Fortune CFO story, August 2015
Facts checked against the cited coverage as of November 2026. No court record, audit or company filing was reviewed. Details such as headcount and pay figure differ between outlets, and this page repeats each as reported. Later events after the August 2015 sale are not covered.