VC
Tender offers and secondary sales of startup shares
A secondary sale means an existing shareholder sells shares that already exist, so the company receives no money and no new shares are issued. A tender offer is the organized version: the company or a lead investor offers to buy shares from many holders at one fixed price during a set window. Both need the company’s cooperation, and neither is guaranteed.
Private company stock has no market. A founder or early employee can hold equity worth a lot on paper for ten years and still be unable to pay for a house with it. Secondary sales exist to loosen that, a little, without waiting for an acquisition or an IPO. This guide explains how the main routes work, what limits them and what to check before selling. It is general information about US practice unless stated otherwise.
The short answer
| Tender offer | Private secondary sale | |
|---|---|---|
| Who starts it | The company or a lead investor | The shareholder |
| Who buys | Usually existing or new investors, sometimes the company itself | A single investor, a fund or a buyer on a marketplace |
| Price | One fixed price for everyone | Negotiated per deal |
| Who can sell | A defined group, often with a cap per person | One seller or a small group |
| Needs company approval | Yes, it is the company’s program | Almost always, through consent and transfer rules |
| Timing | A window of weeks, a few times in a company’s life | Whenever a buyer and the company agree |
Primary versus secondary: why the difference matters
In a primary round, the company issues new shares and receives the cash, which is why it dilutes everyone. In a secondary transaction the shares change hands between owners. The cap table shows a different name next to the same number of shares, and the company’s bank balance does not change. For that reason a secondary does not fund growth, and investors sometimes read a large founder sale as a signal about confidence.
Many financings mix both. A Series B, for instance, can sell new shares to the incoming investor and also let the investor buy some existing shares from founders and early employees in the same closing. Our guide to how a Series A round is structured covers the primary side, and the cap table basics show where the transferred shares end up.
How a company tender offer works
Harness describes a tender offer as a liquidity event in which a company, an investor or a group of investors offers to buy a fixed number of shares from existing shareholders at a set price (guide dated March 15, 2024). The ESO Fund guide, last updated October 2026, adds the mechanics most holders see in practice. The company or its lead investor organizes the offer, the board approves it, and the price, the total number of shares to be bought, the eligible holders and the deadline are fixed in advance.
The usual steps look like this:
- The board decides to run a program, often alongside a new financing that brings in a buyer.
- The company chooses the price, the buyer and the rules for who may sell and how much.
- Eligible holders receive a document with the terms and a deadline. Formal offers, according to ESO Fund, typically stay open at least 20 business days.
- Each holder chooses how many shares to sell, if any. Declining carries no penalty.
- If more shares are offered than the buyer wants, sales may be cut back proportionally, which Harness notes can leave you selling only part of what you tendered.
- The company or the buyer pays the holders, less any tax withholding.
The buyer is usually an investor, but the company can also repurchase the shares itself with its cash. Repurchase uses money the company could have spent on growth, so boards weigh it carefully.
How the price is set
ESO Fund says most startup tender prices land between the company’s latest 409A valuation, which is the fair market value of common stock used for option pricing, and the price investors paid per preferred share in the latest round. Common stock usually sells at a discount to preferred because preferred holders have special rights. A price above the 409A is generally a good sign for sellers, according to the same guide, and a price at or below it deserves a question about why.
Do not read the headline price as a promise about what the shares will be worth later. ESO Fund cites one example from October 2024 in which a company ran a tender at $46.99 per share and went public later at $40. One example proves nothing about averages, but it shows that a tender price is a negotiated number, not a floor.
Who is allowed to sell
Eligibility is the company’s choice. Common rules, per the ESO Fund and Harness guides:
- minimum tenure or a minimum amount of vested equity;
- only shares already owned, so options that have not been exercised do not count;
- a cap on how much any one person may sell, which ESO Fund says is commonly 10 to 25 percent of vested shares;
- restrictions by group, such as current employees only, or excluding former employees.
The cap is a company policy, not a rule of law. Some programs are narrower, some wider, and former employees are often treated differently from current ones.
A worked example (hypothetical)
An employee holds 20,000 vested options with a $2.00 strike price. The company announces a tender at $12.00 per share and caps each person at 20 percent of vested shares.
- Maximum sale: 20 percent of 20,000, which is 4,000 shares.
- Gross proceeds: 4,000 x $12.00 = $48,000.
- Exercise cost for the same 4,000 options: 4,000 x $2.00 = $8,000, paid up front under the usual rule that options must be exercised before they can be sold.
- Before taxes, the spread is $40,000.
The employee keeps 16,000 options. If the company later sells for more than $12 per share, those shares gain; if it sells for less, they lose. The tax result depends on option type and holding period, which is the next section. These numbers are invented for illustration and match no real company.
How a private secondary sale works
In a private secondary sale, a shareholder looks for a buyer instead of waiting for the company to run a program. The buyer might be a fund that specializes in secondaries, an investor already on the cap table or an individual accredited investor. Some marketplaces match sellers and buyers, but each trade still needs the company’s sign-off.
Companies tend to be cautious here because an unfamiliar buyer appears on the cap table without the company choosing them. Typical gates are:
- Right of first refusal (ROFR). Many stock plans and investor agreements let the company, or sometimes its investors, buy the shares on the same terms before an outside buyer can. A ROFR can slow a deal or end it.
- Transfer restrictions. Equity plan documents and bylaws often ban transfers without board approval. Some agreements require approval from a majority of investors for any secondary sale.
- Information rights. A buyer usually wants financial statements and cap table data. Handing them over needs the company’s agreement and often a confidentiality agreement.
- Disclosure about the company. A seller who knows material, non-public news (a planned acquisition, say, or a collapse in revenue) should not trade on it without telling the buyer, and the company may refuse to approve a sale for that reason.
Founder sales raise a further point. Investors sometimes accept a modest founder sale in a large round, especially when it lets a founder stay focused instead of leaving for a salary elsewhere, but they can also object. No standard size exists. How much a founder may sell depends on the stage, the investors’ appetite and what the existing agreements allow, and the sources used here give no verified market figure.
Restrictions that come from securities law
Private shares are usually restricted securities, meaning they were issued without SEC registration and cannot be resold freely. Under Rule 144, securities from a company that does not file periodic reports generally must be held for one year before resale, and the clock starts only after the shares are fully paid for (17 CFR 230.144(d)(1), eCFR, current text). Rule 144 is only one of the ways to resell, and a holder who sells to an accredited investor in a private deal may rely on a different exemption, so the company’s lawyers usually decide the route.
Tender offers have their own rules. SEC staff guidance titled “Tender Offer Rules and Schedules,” last updated July 9, 2026, states that Regulation 14E applies to tender offers for any securities other than exempted securities, whether or not the subject company files periodic reports. That regulation includes the antifraud provision of Section 14(e), so the offer document cannot contain a material misstatement or leave out a material fact. Which other tender offer rules apply, such as the minimum offering period or withdrawal rights, turns on the facts, and companies run these programs with securities counsel. Holders should not try to design one informally by emailing everyone a fixed price and a deadline.
The company’s own agreements add a second layer, and Canadian and other non-US companies have a third in local securities law. This guide describes US rules.
Tax cautions
This section only lists the questions to ask. It gives no tax advice, and the answers depend on country, state, option type and personal facts.
- Option type. ESO Fund notes that selling shares from incentive stock options (ISOs) within one year of exercise or two years of grant is a disqualifying disposition, which can turn the exercise spread into ordinary income. Harness adds that exercising ISOs can trigger the alternative minimum tax, depending on the size of the transaction. Nonqualified options and RSUs are generally taxed as ordinary income at exercise or vesting, then as capital gain or loss on sale.
- Price above fair market value. ESO Fund says that if a company buys shares above fair market value, the IRS may treat the premium as compensation income, and suggests asking the company how it will report the payment.
- Withholding. Proceeds are paid net of withholding, and withholding is not the same as the tax actually owed.
- Qualified small business stock. A holder who expects the shares to qualify should ask a tax adviser how a sale affects that treatment before signing.
Our general overview of founder taxes and the guide to founder equity and stock options cover the background. Whatever the answer is, set money aside for the tax bill before spending any of the cash.
Should you sell? Questions to ask first
Selling can reduce stress, and it can reduce your upside. Some questions help:
- What is the price relative to the last preferred round and the 409A?
- How much of your vested equity are you being allowed to sell, and could a later program be larger or smaller?
- What happens to the shares you keep if the company is sold for less than the preferred stack? The liquidation preference guide explains why common holders can receive little in a modest exit.
- Does the sale change your vesting, your title, your standing with investors or your eligibility for later programs?
- Who is the buyer, and are there side letters, such as a promise to vote shares a certain way?
For many employees the most useful rule is to sell only an amount whose loss would not feel painful if the company later does very well, and to keep the rest as intended upside. That is a personal framework, not advice.
How tender offers fit into a company’s exit picture
A tender is one of several liquidity routes. An IPO, an acquisition or a merger pays all holders at once, though in an order set by the preferred stock terms. Our guide to startup exits and earn-outs compares those. Tender offers are mostly a later-stage tool, because the company needs a buyer with enough capital, enough investor demand and enough years of history to make a program worthwhile. Very early companies rarely run them.
Questions readers ask
Is a secondary sale the same as a tender offer? No. A tender offer is a company-organized program with a fixed price and a window. A secondary sale is a direct transaction between a holder and a buyer, and the company usually has to approve it.
Does a secondary sale dilute other shareholders? No. Existing shares move from one owner to another, and no new shares are created.
Can I sell unexercised options in a tender offer? Generally not directly. Holders usually have to exercise first and pay the strike price and any taxes, according to ESO Fund.
Can a company force me to sell? A normal tender offer is voluntary. Mandatory sales usually arise in other situations, such as drag-along rights in an acquisition.
Do I need the company’s permission to sell privately? Almost always, because of transfer restrictions and rights of first refusal in the equity documents.
Are tender offers common? They are more common at later-stage private companies. The sources used here give no reliable market-wide frequency figure, so this guide gives none.
Sources and limits
- SEC, Division of Corporation Finance, “Tender Offer Rules and Schedules” (sec.gov), updated July 9, 2026, for Regulation 14E.
- eCFR, 17 CFR 230.144(d)(1), for the Rule 144 holding periods (one year for non-reporting issuers).
- ESO Fund, “What Is a Tender Offer? A Guide for Startup Employees” (esofund.com), last updated October 15, 2026, for pricing range, caps, offer window, exercise rule and tax cautions. ESO Fund sells liquidity services and its figures are rules of thumb.
- Harness, “What is a Tender Offer?” (harness.co), March 15, 2024, for tender offer types, proportional cutbacks and tax points.
Many of these sources sell secondary-market or wealth services. Caps, pricing, eligibility and tax treatment differ from company to company and country to country, and the equity documents and the company’s counsel decide any real case. This page covers US practice unless stated otherwise. It is not investment, legal or tax advice.